The Purdue Exponent Online
Tuesday, 3/27/2001
5 day quick link 3/26 | 3/23 | 3/22 | 3/21 | 3/20


Opinions
Provocation law protects guilty

This letter is in response to Drew Bisson's "Hate crime legislation solves nothing."

Is Bisson aware that in the State of Indiana, and many other states, a defendant is able to plea not guilty in lieu of irrevocable provocation? What this intends is, "I clubbed you over the head because you were flirting with me and I'm not gay" or "This person was talking to me about racism, and I simply got sick of talking about it and clubbed him." Irrevocable provocation is defined in code as provocation that is suggestive and unfounded. Its most recent use in Indiana courts was two years ago when the Indianapolis Police Department used it in its defense in the bar incident involving three black men and four Indiana Police officers. The police department won that case.

Irrevocable provocation protects, yes, protects the guilty in times of discussion of social-sensitive subjects including religion, sexuality and race.

Drew, I suggest you review your comments and stop adding to the social ignorance that plagues Purdue.

Charles Lamb

Junior, School of Liberal Arts

 

Related Coverage

 

Column

PSG referendum proves unethical, illegal

Students should partake in PSG decisions

Editorial

 

Letters

Exams conflict with night classes

Death receives excessive coverage

Reader disagrees with editorial staff

Anti-cheering fans upsets student

Purdue needs bins to recycle plastics

Ice hockey surpasses basketball

University should not lower standards

Faith means trusting, not questioning

Provocation law protects guilty

 

Contact us

OPINIONS DESK PHONE:
(765) 743-1111 ext. 256

Opinions editor:
Tom McHenry

Extra

Online Columnist Archive

 






Purdue Exponent 2001