The Purdue Exponent Online
Friday, 4/6/2001
5 day quick link 4/5 | 4/4 | 4/3 | 4/2 | 3/30



Opinions

People could abuse hate crime laws

Mr. Hoffman, your April 2 Exponent letter was absolutely correct about intention and legal distinctions, and about the intended application of the hate crime legislation. As a matter of fact, juries (whether the jury consists of just a judge or a six- or 12-person jury) base convictions on their perception of the intent of the accused. Also, the basic premise of the law is that it is to be applied evenly and without prejudice. That is the theory, now lets talk a little bit about reality

I think that most people would be fine with hate crime legislation if they believed it would be written intelligently and difficult to abuse. Unfortunately, that requires trust in people who have shown that they are willing to go along with a knee jerk reaction now, for the sake of popularity, and try to fix it later. We all have our jaded beliefs, and we assume that most people think along the same lines that we do. These beliefs, right or wrong, give us our range of perceptions. I actually believed for a while that racism towards African-Americans was pretty much gone in this country, and if I was on a jury, that belief could have influenced my judgement, and this is were the problem lies. I am not the only person who has and/or does hold a belief to be true that is inappropriate. Knowing that others may believe differently allows people to see how laws, not just hate crime legislation, can be manipulated. Seeing a potential for injustice that is presented in the name of justice makes people worry. People can't be blamed for that. What hate crime proponents need to do is to find a way to assuage that fear, not condemn them, which seems to be your intent.

Richard Hayward
Graduate Student

 

Related Coverage

 

Column

PSG damages its credibility with repeal

Editorial

Police should not target spectators

4th and inches comic

Letters

Trash doesn't biodegrade faster on Purdue campus

University should donate old computers, programs

Basketball excites crowd with scoring

People could abuse hate crime laws

Advertisements don't belong on Hello Walk plaques

Troubled students should get help

Behavior disappoints Purdue alumna

People should respect gay activists

Fans shouldn't focus on NASCAR driver's death

Contact us

OPINIONS DESK PHONE:
(765) 743-1111 ext. 256

Opinions editor:
Tom McHenry

Extra

Online Columnist Archive

 






Purdue Exponent 2001