|
|

Writer's arguments need
more research for better credibility
Although I do not agree with this proclamation, I could probably make
an argument for it if I back it up with general statements and stereotypes
a technique used by Ian Clift in his column "United Nations has
become a tyrannical beast" published on Jan 31.
In this piece, Clift takes statements such as, "A number of disturbing
parallels exist between our own United States and the United Nations,"
and "It starts out with good intentions usually with a list of objectives
(left vague in order for corruption to occur) and progresses into something
much bigger and more ominous than before." These foreboding statements
are then backed as follows. The disturbing parallels: both the United
States and the United Nations start with the word "United." Oddly enough,
that is the only disturbing parallel that he lists. He mentions the
fact that the United States is in the United Nations and the fact that
it aids the United Nations, but that makes sense since it is a member
of the United Nations, right? Does membership make it a parallel? The
second statement is vague. The "it" that "starts out with good intentions"
could mean most anything. I'll take it to mean a political institution
since that's what would make the most sense. Of course, in almost all
institutions there is corruption, but since the United Nations has 189
members, those few corrupt members are held in check by the wishes of
the other 180 or so members. That's a parallel to the United States
government, but holding corruption in check isn't a disturbing parallel,
is it? What Clift is doing here is making pointless anti-American and
anti-UN accusations backed with arguments that are ad ignorum. Maybe
those who would like to write about politics should do more than minimal
research first.
Ken Moore
Senior, School of Liberal Arts
|
U.S.
employers treat women unequally to men
Students
offer concept for new group, specify joining requirements
Taking
away e-mail shows how Purdue removes privileges
Many
vegetarians make smart choices for not eating meat
Writer's
arguments need more research for better credibility
Exponent
staff writers should increase effort toward their research
Pairs
of shoes hanging on phone lines prompt questions about origin
U.S.
recycling policies should increase efforts toward conservation
Parking
tickets, meters, police all serve purpose of upholding laws, rules
Butchering
puppies should remain act of professionals
Martins
Cartoon
OPINIONS DESK PHONE:
(765) 743-1111
ext. 256
Opinions editor:
John Wakefield
To
send a letter to the editor, please email opinions@purdueexponent.org

|