The Purdue Exponent Online
03/29/2002
Previous Edition 3/28


Opinions

Letter respondent hopes to educate objecting writers

Ms. Ramos (Exponent letter, March 22), I tried contacting you directly, but you do not appear in the Purdue phone book or the Faculty/Staff database. I think I can make this sufficiently valuable to warrant another Exponent entry.

I was upset that one person chose to misquote me in order to support an inane position, and that another two chose to misrepresent what I had written in order to, mostly, reiterate what I had already said and in the same stroke impugn my integrity. And yes, the responses I wrote were in a voice designed to get that point across. They, as well as others, need to understand that what they did will not be tolerated. There is, however, a larger issue. Did you note that in my responses I noted some problems/flaws in their letters, and in the case of the pair who wanted to refute my statements I actually invited them to try again? If they do try again, do you think that their response will be more accurate and informative, or that it will be the same jumbled mass of ideas tossed onto a sheet of paper as before? I am willing to bet their response will have improved and they will have learned something important that they will be able to use in any profession they choose. If they take my rebuke and invitation seriously they will gain a self-taught lesson in critical reading and logical response, and that is something that can only be self-taught. I may have wasted my time, but my hope is that they gain an important learning experience. So maybe you should be a little less quick to judge, unless you believe that the opinions column is not a proper venue for learning.

Richard Hayward
Graduate student


Related Coverage

 

Column

 

Editorial

Library rating does not necessitate concern

Letters

Governor's budget disappoints loyal democratic voter

Misrepresentation of interior design club jades views

Creationism could cause ethnocentrism similar to religions

Creationism letter displays author's misunderstanding

Purdue's innovation stops at ice polishers, creates risky walks

Religion fails as link between al-Qaida, Ku Klux Klan beliefs

Letter respondent hopes to educate objecting writers

University needs to buy snowplows to replace brushes

Killing terrorists does not prove to end violence

Contact us

OPINIONS DESK PHONE:
(765) 743-1111 ext. 256

Opinions editor: John Wakefield

To send a letter to the editor, please email opinions@purdueexponent.org

Extra

 





Purdue Exponent 2002